Striking the Right Balance Between Co-Operation and Competition: Several Antitrust Pitfalls in R&D Alliances and Other Strategic Partnerships

January 2012

Abstract

The aim of this article is to provide guidance to in-house counsel on the assessment and management of key risks associated with partnership opportunities. As such, in-house counsel should be able to quickly identify the antitrust risks related to each type of partnership (joint R&D, joint purchasing, joint manufacturing and/or joint marketing), taking in account the evolution in 2010 and 2011 of the EU regulatory framework on co-operations among firms. The authors highlight the various criteria needed to ensure antitrust compliance (e.g. market shares, threshold issues etc.) and the tricky practical situations that may arise (e.g. information exchange among partners, new “safe harbour” conditions regarding agreements in restraint of trade). The article also addresses the cornerstone issue of discussing upfront among potential partners the access to and allocation of background and foreground Intellectual Property Rights (IPR), failing which the partnership may derail and lead to costly litigation and detrimental business consequences. In this respect, the authors stress how undue IPR restrictions may have an impact on the antitrust analysis of a partnership, this interaction illustrating the growing tension among antitrust and IP topics in high-tech business

Author

Iohann Le Frapper

Chief Legal Officer, Gulf Bridge International , Qatar

Active legal manager with wide global and regional experience with first-tier companies like Total and Alcatel-Lucent. Corporate generalist with unique exposure to emerging markets like BRICS countries. Handling corporate and commercial transactions across Europe, USA, Middle-East, Africa and Asia Pacific regions. Board member of ACC Vice-chair of ICC corporate responsibility & anti-corruption international commission 3-year expatriate in Shanghai. Significant experience of managing remotely multi-cultural teams.

On the occasion of the implementation of the ECN+ directive, the Austrian legislator introduced some important changes to the Austrian merger rules last year, which are applicable to Austrian mergers...Read more

Ferdinand Graf

Partner, Graf Isola, Austria

Robert Gulla

General Counsel, Lukoil, Austria

Sarah Kasslatter

Associate, Graf Isola, Austria

Andreas Edlinger

Attorney at Law, Graf Isola, Austria

Will New York’s Indexed Payments for Tier 1 Renewable Energy Credits (“IRECs”) Hurt It’s Voluntary Corporate and Industrial (“C&I”) Renewable Energy Market?

Spurred by an imperative for durable energy offtake, long-term price certainty, improving project economics, and corporate social responsibility to combat climate change, corporate and non-utility industrial (“C&I”) buyers of renewable...Read more

Kingsley Osei

Lead Project Counsel, State University of New York, USA

The Role of Competition in the Construction of the EU Internal Energy Market From the Prism of the Power Exchange

Power Exchanges (PX) have been at the cornerstone of the liberalisation of the wholesale electricity market in the 1990s and then of the integration of the single internal electricity market...Read more

Zohra Boumedhel

Head of Legal Affairs, Epex Spot, France

Antoine Donne

Legal Counsel, Epex Spot, France

Transparency and Fair Competition of Procurement.

There are long-established prejudices around Russia with its high level of corruption, and unfair competition in the business environment, which have been addressed in recent years by the introduction of...Read more

Yulianna Vertinskaya

Head of Legal Department, Renewable & Ethics and Compliance Ambassador at ALSTOM, ALSTOM, Russia & CIS, Russia

Striking the Right Balance Between Co-Operation and Competition: Several Antitrust Pitfalls in R&D Alliances and Other Strategic Partnerships

Abstract

Author

Company

Gulf Bridge International

Related Papers