Interpreting Business Rescue Provisions of the South African Companies Act 71 of 2008: Secured Pre-Commencement Finance Versus Post-Commencement Finance

October 2016

Abstract

The South African Companies Act provides for a business rescue process. A current interpretational issue relates to the ranking of claims of creditors who provided secured Pre-commencement Finance in relation to claims of creditors providing Post-commencement Finance. This paper presents an analysis of sections 134 and 135 of the Companies Act, as well as relevant case law. It is argued that two South African High Court judgments have incorrectly attributed to Post-commencement Finance a higher level of seniority in relation to secured Pre-commencement Finance than the provisions of the Companies Act do. A brief comparison with four international legal systems regarding rescue finance and super-priority issues is also provided. It is recommended that the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission be approached with a request to apply for a declaratory court order as provided for in section 188(2)(b)(ii) of the Companies Act, alternatively that amendments to the Companies Act be made.

Author

Stef Du Plessis

In-house Legal Adviser, Corporate and Investment Banking, a division of The Standard Bank of South Africa Limited, South Africa

The author holds a LLD degree (Doctor Legum) in the law of contract, is a qualified Attorney and Notary under the laws of South Africa, and is an in-house legal adviser in the Corporate and Investment Banking division of The Standard Bank of South Africa Limited.

The digitalization of financial services is supporting the simplification of day-to-day life, making financial services available round the clock and easily accessible to the most remote parts of the globe....Read more

Andreas Gustafsson

Senior Advisor, Nasdaq, Sweden

Sofia Skroubi

Senior Associate General Counsel, Nasdaq , Sweden

SWIPE, CHIP, TAP: Regulatory Dynamics in the Card Payment Industry and its Impact on Financial Inclusion

The card payment industry has undergone significant transformations with the advent of innovative payment technologies. This paper explores the regulatory dynamics shaping the industries and their consequential effects on financial...Read more

Jesse Mudaliyar

Senior Managing Counsel, VP, Mastercard EEMEA , UAE

Proposed FDIC Guidelines with Impose New Responsibilities on Directors of FDIC-Insured Banks

On October 11, 2023, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (the “FDIC”) issued proposed mandatory Guidelines (the “Guidelines”) concerning the roles and responsibilities of directors of banks whose deposits are insured...Read more

Bruce Ortwine

General Counsel (retired), Americas; Adviser, Global Legal and Compliance (Retired), Sumitomo Mitsui Trust Bank, Limited and Sumitomo Mitsui Trust Holdings, Inc., USA

Certain Regulatory Reporting Requirements for a Foreign Banking Organization in the United States

My former employer of thirty-three years is a Japanese financial institution (the “Bank”) and is subject to comprehensive regulation in the United States at both the Federal and State levels....Read more

Bruce Ortwine

General Counsel (retired), Americas; Adviser, Global Legal and Compliance (Retired), Sumitomo Mitsui Trust Bank, Limited and Sumitomo Mitsui Trust Holdings, Inc., USA

Interpreting Business Rescue Provisions of the South African Companies Act 71 of 2008: Secured Pre-Commencement Finance Versus Post-Commencement Finance

Abstract

Author

Company

Corporate and Investment Banking, a division of The Standard Bank of South Africa Limited

Related Papers