This website uses cookies

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience. By using our website, you agree to our Privacy Policy

International In-house Counsel Journal logoInternational In-house Counsel Journal logo
Back to library search

Smart v ComReg (2006): Lessons Learnt from Successfully Defending Private and Public Law Proceedings

Abstract

The purpose of this article is to identify lessons learnt from successfully defending the private and public law proceedings initiated by Smart Mobile Limited in respect of the decision of ComReg to withdraw its offer of the fourth 3G mobile telecommunications licence from Smart: Smart v ComReg (2006).

Author

Mark Hughes
Head of Regulatory, Hutchison 3G Ireland Limited, Ireland

Mark Hughes is a qualified solicitor working in the Commission for Communications Regulation (”ComReg”). With a background in corporate finance and commercial law, Mark is an expert in: (i) regulatory law and practice; and (ii) litigation. Mark has advised in respect of: (i) the award of the fourth and final Irish 3G mobile telecommunications licence; (ii) the drafting of Part 3 (Aviation Regulation) of the State Airports Act, 2004 (providing for the re-structuring of Aer Rianta); and (iii) the €3.7 billion acquisition of Eircell Limited by Vodafone Group plc. In addition, Mark recently successfully defended private and public law proceedings in respect of the award of the fourth and final Irish 3G mobile telecommunications licence. This involved: (i) the management of an external legal team of six lawyers; and (ii) being a witness as to fact.

Company

Hutchison 3G Ireland Limited

ComReg is the Irish State body responsible for regulating the electronic communications sector, the postal sector and in part, the broadcasting sector. ComReg is not responsible for the regulation of content in the broadcasting sector. In respect of the electronic communications sector, ComReg’s objectives are: (i) to promote competition; (ii) to contribute to the development of the European Community internal market; and (iii) to promote the interests of users within the European Community. In respect of the postal sector, ComReg’s objective is to promote the development of the postal sector. ComReg is responsible for the management of Irish radio frequency spectrum and the Irish national numbering resource. ComReg was established in 2002 and took over from its predecessor, the Office of the Director of Telecommunications Regulation (established in 1996). For more information in respect of ComReg, please see: www.comreg.ie.

Related Papers

EU Merger Control Procedure – A Brief Overview
This paper provides an introductory overview of the EU merger control procedure, explaining the main terms and principles and showing the practical implications on notifiable transactions. 1. Legal Framework The EU merger control...Read more
Portrait image of Thomas Wiese
Thomas Wiese
Case Handler, Directorate-General of Competition of the European Commission, Unit C-5 Mergers, Belgium
Practical Aspects of Protection of Collective Consumer Interests – Overview of Measures Applied by the Polish Office of Competition and Consumer Protection
In Poland, protection of consumer interests and protection of competition has been entrusted to one institution, the one I am in charge of. The Polish Antimonopoly Office was established in...Read more
Portrait image of Marek Niechcial
Marek Niechcial
President, Poland's Office of Competition and Consumer Protection, Poland
Cartel Enforcement in Ireland since the Downturn
This article first explores some of the enhancements to the competition enforcement regime in Ireland and organisational changes to the Irish Competition Authority since 2010. It then addresses my personal...Read more
Portrait image of Eoghan Ó hArgáin
Eoghan Ó hArgáin
Case Officer/Solicitor, Ireland's Competition Authority, Ireland
The Certain Aspects of Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A) in Pharmaceutical Industries Relating the Antitrust and IPR Rules of the EU acquis communautaire
The prescription of the Article 152 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (furthermore: TFEU), provides special provisions that establish the importance of the public health....Read more
Portrait image of Mirna Pavletic-Zupic
Mirna Pavletic-Zupic
Member, Croatian Competition Council, Croatian Competition Agency, Croatia