This website uses cookies

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience. By using our website, you agree to our Privacy Policy

International In-house Counsel Journal logoInternational In-house Counsel Journal logo

The Use of Mediation in Settling Patent Disputes

Abstract

Multinational patent disputes are highly complex as they frequently deal with complicated technical facts and arguments that must be presented in numerous jurisdictions with different legal systems and jurisdictional traditions. Court proceedings are often lengthy and expensive, and frequently there is a considerable risk of obtaining an unfavorable decision in at least one jurisdiction. Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) methods are an attractive and powerful alternative to traditional patent litigation. Mediation, as one of the ADR methods, offers the involved parties the opportunity to settle all related disputes with the assistance of a mediator in one fell swoop, reaching a global settlement and achieving immediate legal certainty in all jurisdictions involved. Despite these obvious advantages, it remains that mediation is not as extensively used in patent matters as it could be. This article aims to illustrate the characteristics of mediation in a patent dispute, as well as the advantages of mediation over traditional patent litigation as well as its limitations.

Read Paper

Authors

Portrait image of Friederike  Heckmann
Friederike Heckmann
Senior Patent Counsel, Bayer Intellectual Property GmbH, Germany

Dr. Friederike Heckmann is a senior patent counsel at Bayer Intellectual Property GmbH in the area of Crop Science. She is mainly focusing on global prosecution, litigation and mediation, and has special expertise in the area of SPCs. She graduated in chemistry from the Philipps-University of Marburg and University of Cambridge, and obtained her doctoral thesis from the Ludwig-Maximilians University of Munich. In 2005 she started her career in the IP business, working for a well-known patent law firm in Munich. After 10 years in private practice, she changed position and began working for Bayer Intellectual Property GmbH. Dr. Heckmann is qualified as a German and European Patent Attorney.

Portrait image of Thorsten Bausch
Thorsten Bausch
Partner, Hoffmann Eitle, Germany

Dr. Thorsten Bausch is a senior partner at the IP law firm Hoffmann Eitle with offices in Munich, London, Milano, Madrid, Duesseldorf, Hamburg and Amsterdam. He is co-head of Hoffmann Eitle’s chemistry group and concentrates on chemical and biotech patents, with a particular emphasis on litigation (both cross-border and national), oppositions, appeals and alternative dispute resolution. His main technical expertise is in the areas of pharmaceuticals, polymers and immunology. Dr. Bausch has been involved with numerous cases before the EPO Opposition Divisions, Boards of Appeal, including the Enlarged Board of Appeal, the German Federal Patent Court, the German Federal Court of Justice, and the European Court of Justice. He is the editor of "Nichtigkeitsrechtsprechung in Patentsachen" (German Patent Nullity Cases), a four-volume collection of decisions of the Federal Patent Court and the Federal Court of Justice on patent nullity matters; author of numerous articles on German and European patent law in renowned journals and a frequent lecturer in and outside of Germany on patent law subjects. In addition, Dr. Bausch regularly blogs on www.kluwerpatentblog.com

Companies

Bayer Intellectual Property GmbH

Bayer Intellectual Property GmbH is an affiliated Company of Bayer AG handling the entire IP.

Hoffmann Eitle

Related Papers

Beyond Stereotypes: Cross-Cultural Differences that Matter for Lawyers
In over two decades as the head of litigation for international companies, I encountered questions of whether cultural differences contributed to our contract disputes with parties in different countries. These...Read more
Portrait image of Michael Mcilwrath
Michael Mcilwrath
ICC Dispute Resolution Services, CEO, MDisputes, Italy
Compliance Programs: Step-by-Step Guide to Building and Scaling Effective Programs from Start-Ups to Large Enterprises
Business operates in a world of risks including geopolitical, regulatory, environmental, and macroeconomic. Many of these risks cannot be controlled. On the other hand, “conduct based risk”, or risks stemming...Read more
Portrait image of Gunnar Wieboldt
Gunnar Wieboldt
Former SVP, General Counsel, Vestaron Corporation, USA
The UK Arbitration Bill : what do you need to know?
On 18 July 2024, the Arbitration Bill was introduced in the House of Lords. The aim of the Bill is to update the current arbitral framework, the Arbitration Act 1996...Read more
Portrait image of Ashleigh Brocchieri
Ashleigh Brocchieri
Expert Counsel, International Chamber of Commerce, France
Portrait image of Colleen Parker-Bacquet
Colleen Parker-Bacquet
Counsel, ICC International Court of Arbitration, France
Contract Mapping: Taking the Diligence Room and Contract Transparency to the Next Level
Traditional methods of tracking contracts miss the opportunity to provide meaningful context and insight relating to the contracts of the company to management, the board members, auditors, and investors. ...Read more
Portrait image of Gunnar Wieboldt
Gunnar Wieboldt
Former SVP, General Counsel, Vestaron Corporation, USA